Unfair Dismissal and Constructive Dismissal
1. Introduction Constructive dismissal is one of the more difficult routes to a successful unfair dismissal complaint. It requires the employee to terminate the employment relationship and then to demonstrate, in the WRC, that the resignation was the necessary and proportionate response to the employer’s conduct. The burden of proof rests with the employee. This
Read More
Constructive Dismissal in Ireland: What You Need to Prove and Where Most Claims Fail
Constructive Dismissal Law In Practice Constructive dismissal is one of the most misunderstood areas of Irish employment law. Many employees walk out of a toxic workplace believing they have a strong case, only to find their claim fails on a technicality they could have avoided. If you’re considering resigning because of how you’ve been treated
Read More
Constructive Dismissal and Harassment in the Workplace
Background The case of Care Worker v Costern Unlimited Company (ADJ00046268) examines the circumstances under which it will be deemed reasonable for an employee to resign and bring a claim of unfair dismissal by way of constructive dismissal on foot of a failure of their employer to properly investigate their complaints. A Care Worker (the
Read More
Burden of Proof in Constructive Dismissal Claims
Background The case of Mark Lowry v JJ Fleming and Company Limited (ADJ00036677) examines the burden of proof issues that often arise in constructive dismissal claims. Uniquely, the employer offered no substantive evidence to support their case, yet won, highlighting the very difficult hurdles an employee often faces in bringing an unfair dismissal claim, following
Read More
Working Excessive Hours and Constructive Dismissal
Excessive Working Hours and Constructive Dismissal Can an employee resign if they are working excessive hours? Can they then pursue a claim of unfair dismissal by way of constructive dismissal? The case of Melissa Moran v C.H. Kane Ltd Supervalu (ADJ – 000316262) was decided on 08 June 2022. This case is interesting because it
Read More
Constructive Dismissal v Resignation
Are all Resignations Constructive Dismissals? The Unfair Dismissals Act envisages two situations whereby a termination of the employment relationship can occur. In the first situation, the employer ends the employment relationship. In general, an employer will be required to prove that the ending of the employment relationship was fair and reasonable which will usually result
Read More
Agency Workers and Constructive Dismissal
Introduction A job for life is now the market exception. Previously, employees would join a company and expect to remain with that company benefitting from promotions and salary increases until their retirement. However, as society has changed, so have our methods of working. The gig economy has exploded and workers are now in a more
Read More
Guide to Constructive Dismissal in Ireland
Constructive Dismissal Law Resources: Guide to Constructive Dismissal under Irish Employment Law Guide to Unfair Dismissal under Irish Employment Law Bringing a Constructive Dismissal Claim Constructive Dismissal Cases and Claims Constructive Dismissal under Irish Employment Law (Video) Constructive Dismissal Under Irish Employment Law Section 1(b) of the Unfair Dismissals Act defines constructive dismissal as “the
Read More
